PART-TIME 4X4 OR FULL-TIME 4X4? ARE THREE DIFFS BETTER THAN TWO? THESE ARE THE QUESTIONS ROAD-TEST EDITOR FRASER STRONACH PONDERS ON A RAINY DAY.
I t’s early January on the Bells Line of Road just west of Sydney and it’s bucketing down rain, and the road is awash. I’m driving a basespec Hilux Workmate. While I’m grateful for having a high-riding 4x4 in these conditions, I can’t help but think how much better off I’d be with full-time 4x4 rather than a part-time 4x4.
The combination of winding mountain roads and lots of water – sometimes in puddles; other times in streams – puts a premium on traction, and with only the rears driving and no weight in the tray, there’s plenty of work to be done by the electronic traction and stability control systems, a burden that would be eased with proper full-time 4x4.
Unfortunately, full-time 4x4 utes are few and far between, and only Mitsubishi’s Triton GLS and Exceed models and Volkswagen’s Amarok, with the eightspeed automatic gearbox, fit the bill.
The essential difference between part-time and fulltime 4x4 is the addition of a centre differential, to make three diffs in total, rather than just two.
Mitsubishi’s Super Select, as fitted to the mid- and top-spec Tritons, has a mechanical centre diff that can be manually locked by the driver by moving the shift dial (or lever, depending on the Mitsubishi in question) from 4H to 4HLC, where LC stands for ‘Locked Centre’.
Once the Super Select centre diff is locked the 4x4 system effectively operates like a part-time 4x4 system.
With the centre diff unlocked, it operates like a fulltime 4x4 system.
Mitsubishi modelled Super Select on Jeep’s 1983 Selec-Trac 4x4 system but added a more logical shift sequence in place of Jeep’s confusing arrangement.
But while the Triton system is good, and a significant improvement on the part-time 4x4 systems that are standard ute fare, the Amarok takes things further – in fact, several steps further.
In the Amarok, the driver doesn’t have to lock the centre diff, as that happens automatically if – and when – needed, via an electronic clutch that relies on the wheel-speed sensors to tell it what’s happening in terms of the traction available at each wheel.
While it is at it, the ‘smart’ centre diff on the Amarok can also proportion the drive to the axle that can most use it. When climbing a steep off-road incline, for example, and the rears have lots of traction and the fronts have little, it can direct as much drive as needed to the rear axle.
That’s something that a part-time 4x4 can’t do with its fixed 50/50 front/rear drive.
This helped make the Amarok a standout on the steep climbs when we tested all eight of the popular utes back-to-back last year.
When Toyota released the new Hilux the word was it didn’t come with full-time 4x4 because not having full-time 4x4 saves fuel. This may be true, but the savings would be insignificant at best, and where does that leave the Land Cruiser 200 and Prado, both of which have fulltime 4x4?
It’s a pity that Toyota didn’t slot the Prado’s full-time 4x4 system under the new Hilux. For that matter, it’s a shame Ford didn’t use the Everest’s full-time 4x4 system under the heavily revised Ranger.
www.4X4australia.com.au 23 All new Hilux 4x4s have what Toyota calls an ‘Automatic Disconnecting Differential’ (ADD) as an alternative to freewheeling hubs and as a fuel-saving measure. Without freewheeling hubs or ADD, the front wheels will turn the front half shafts, the front diff and the front prop shaft when a parttime 4x4 is in two-wheel-drive, all of which is unnecessary and a waste of energy. Freewheeling hubs solve this problem but are inconvenient, as you have to get out of the vehicle to engage them. Toyota’s ADD also solves this problem, although without driver intervention – but it is more complicated.
ADD uses a sliding sleeve on the left-side front half shaft that effectively disconnects the leftside front wheel from the front diff. While the right-side half shaft stays connected to the diff, it can only turn the diff internals, which without drive from the left-side drive half shaft means the diff’s ring and pinion gears, and the front prop shaft, don’t turn – until, of course, you engage 4wd.