War Wagons

Two tempting estates for people with stuff to lug in a hurry Ė one brilliant, one disappointing

by SCOTT NEWMAN pics NATHAN JACOBS

THE DUEL Subaru Levorg GT-S vs Skoda Octavia RS230

Two tempting estates for people with stuff to lug in a hurry Ė one brilliant, one disappointing

THE performance wagon is an endangered species. Despite being the perfect car for many needs, itís under significant pressure from a fast SUV onslaught that threatens to overwhelm the marketplace.

Thankfully, small pockets of resistance remain, for buyers who prioritise performance, dynamics, value and efficiency over a lofty driving position and adherence to the latest trend.

A mainstay in this segment is the Skoda Octavia RS, its combination of proven German mechanicals and Eastern European modesty, not to mention value for money, making it a surprise hit. It appears Aussies prefer their Skodas on the spicy side, too, with the RS accounting for 40 per cent of Octavia sales, more than any other variant.

In an effort to reward this loyal and enthusiastic customer base, Skoda Australia has secured a small allocation of the limited edition RS230, which essentially packs the mechanicals from the Golf GTI Performance into the larger, more practical Octavia bodyshell. The result is 169kW/350Nm from the 2.0-litre turbocharged four-cylinder, fed to the front wheels through a six-speed manual and mechanical limited-slip differential. No XDL electronic trickery here, and no lurchy dual-clutch íbox, either.

Thereís also a fairly staggering amount of standard equipment. For $43,190 in wagon form (the sedan is $2000 cheaper) the RS230 offers active cruise control, heated front and rear seats, dual-zone climate control, panoramic sunroof, sat-nav and support for Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, a feature Ferrari charges $6790 for in a 488.

An extra $1700 buys the Tech Pack, which adds a 10-speaker sound system, keyless entry and start, park assist and lane assist.

You can see where dollars have been saved in the interior as thereís a lot of hard, scratchy plastic, however everything you interact with feels quality and the seats look very cool in a retro í80s supercar kind of way, though they could use more lateral support. The boot is a spacious 588 litres with the rear seats up and roomy 1718L with them down, though unfortunately the rear seats donít fold flat.

Nonetheless, itís a more practical load space than that of the new Subaru Levorg, which offers 522L with the seats up and 1446L with them down, though the rear seats do fold almost flat. Three grades of Levorg are offered, from the $42,990 GT to the $52,890 GT-S Spec B. The latter can be seen in our photos, chosen thanks to its array of STI parts, including body kit, black 18s, front strut brace and interior bits.

For the purposes of our comparison, however, weíve used the mid-spec $48,890 GT-S as itís the best match for the Skoda equipment-wise, including features such as a sunroof, auto wipers and headlights, electric heated front leather seats, sat-nav and Subaruís Vision Assist active safety system, all of which are missing in the more price-competitive base GT.

Material quality is superior in the Subaru, with blue-stitched leather where youíd find hard plastic

The performance wagon is under threat from a fast SUV onslaught, despite being the perfect car for the needs of many

in the Skoda, and the latest infotainment system is a big improvement over the old unit that still serves in various Toyotas. Like the Octavia, the Levorg has a full suite of active safety systems including precollision warning, lane departure warning, blind-spot monitoring and more, though the systems in both cars are irritatingly intrusive and usually switched off, albeit for different reasons.

The Subaruís pre-collision alert is hyperactively sensitive, constantly triggering at objects that pose no threat, immediate or otherwise. Likewise, the Skodaís lane-keep assist constantly nudges the steering; the adjustments are subtle, but eventually youíll notice the steering feels weird and given the system wonít actually complete a corner for you, whatís the point?

Thankfully for those who actually pay attention while driving, both systems can be deactivated.

Sadly, one electronic aid that canít be completely turned off is the Skodaís traction control and ESP system. Even with ESP Sport engaged, the system will still grab at spinning wheels, which costs it precious tenths on the drag strip. The best the RS230 can manage is 0-100km/h in 6.96sec and a 15.03sec quarter mile at 160.68km/h; this more or less matches Skodaís 6.9sec 0-100km/h claim, however itís miles off our best of 6.30sec and 14.60sec in a regular manual RS sedan. From memory, that car allowed the

The CVT ensures thereís zero drama, simply plant the foot and wait ... traction gives it a crucial advantage against the clock

traction control to be deactivated completely, so a new software update could be to blame.

Being all-wheel drive, the Levorg has none of these issues and its 197kW/350Nm 2.0-litre turbocharged boxer four fires it to 100km/h in 6.25sec and through the quarter mile in 14.48sec at 158.06km/h. The CVT ensures thereís zero fuss or drama, simply plant the foot and wait. In reality, the two are almost identical in pace, recording very similar trap speeds and separated by just 0.03sec to 160km/h, but the Subaruís traction gives it a crucial advantage against the clock.

Most enthusiasts instinctively, and rightly, recoil in horror at any mention of the word CVT, but the Levorgís transmission isnít the impediment to enjoyment you might expect. Thereís a substantial hesitation from rest, however, unless youíre really trying to fire off the line itís not a huge problem and the take-up is at least smooth. Around town itís well behaved and unobtrusive, while locked in manual mode the CVT offers eight Ďratiosí that can be selected reasonably promptly via paddles on the steering wheel.

Unfortunately, the engine itís attached to is quite uninspiring. Weíre not fond of the FA20 engine in the WRX and its installation in the Levorg does nothing to change that view. The CVT disguises the somewhat lumpy power curve found in the manual WRX well and thereís plenty of power available, but while the engine will rev past its 6500rpm redline the strong focus on mid-range torque makes doing so largely redundant.

Thereís also precious little in the way of aural character. The raucous boxer burble of old might not be appropriate in the more sensible Levorg, but the baleful whine emitted by the FA20 under heavy load discourages enthusiastic driving, suggesting it would rather you calmed down and stopped accelerating so hard. Effective, but not especially exciting, sums up the Levorgís drivetrain.

Like the Subaru, the Skoda will rev past its 6500rpm redline but thereís little point in doing so; it feels more effective to grab the next gear at around 5000rpm and let those 350Nm do the work. The gearshift doesnít feel quite as accurate as the equivalent Golf GTI íbox Ė though this was a very fresh car Ė but the shift is light, accurate and easy to use.

There is a small degree of turbo lag but the midrange is very strong; however, slightly frustratingly, this then fails to materialise into anything worthwhile at the top end. Itís a shame Skoda didnít manage to secure the Golf GTI 40 Years engine for the limitededition RS230, as in 195kW tune the EA888 is much more aggressive in character with a hunger for revs, and any fears the extra power would overwhelm the Skodaís chassis are dispelled by the fact the two variants produce an identical 350Nm of torque Ė the Golfís extra urge is all at the top end. For Skoda to score the gun Golfís tune would upset VWís carefully orchestrated model hierarchy, but if youíre going to make an enthusiastsí special, go the whole hog.

Itís a small complaint, however, as the RS230 feels

to have the perfect amount of grunt for its chassis.

Thereís a degree of torque steer on bumpy roads and clumsy throttle inputs can induce wheelspin exiting tight corners, but in general traction is strong. Turbo front-drivers these days often have too much torque to effectively harness without electronic intervention, but the Skodaís combination of a limited-slip diff and 225/40 R19 Pirelli P Zero rubber proves formidable.

The Skodaís suspension setup is relatively soft; it lacks Volkswagenís DCC adaptive dampers, but the tune feels to be roughly halfway between the Normal and Sport modes. This might cost it a few tenths around a racetrack compared to a stiffer setup, but itís spot on for road use. The ride is beautifully judged, a great balance between control and compliance. It is firm and a little jittery over small imperfections, but the vast majority of road irritations are filtered out before reaching the occupants.

This slight softness occasionally becomes apparent at the limit, most notably through large compressions taken at speed or during quick changes of direction where the RS230 can feel a little ponderous. In general, though, it works in the Skodaís favour, the suspension soaking up bumps rather than allowing them to deflect the carís trajectory and the increased body movement makes it more involving. The rear can be bought into play slightly, but ESP Sport isnít lenient enough to let it wander too far.

The brakes are slightly over-assisted around town, but when you dig into them on a twisty road they provide great feel and plenty of staying power. Itís easy to heel-and-toe as well. About the only real dynamic criticism of the RS230 involves the steering. It uses the variable-rate rack from the Golf GTI, which feels slightly at odds with the Skodaís larger steering wheel.

It exacerbates the dullness around the straight ahead and applying the correct amount of lock for a given corner can take a bit of guesswork. Itís a small blemish on an otherwise impressive report card.

In contrast, the Levorg needs to be sent straight to the principalís office. Itís difficult to know where to begin with a chassis that feels so ill-resolved and under-developed. How a team of engineers could spend what was presumably a lot of time, effort and money and have the end result be so compromised is hard to comprehend, especially for a brand like Subaru that trades on its sporting heritage.

The conservative calibration of the ESP system raises the suspicion that Subaru knows the Levorgís suspension isnít up to par. Even when switched Ďoffí itís constantly intervening in an effort to keep everything shipshape, probably because on a bumpy road the wheels feel to spend as much time in the air as on the road. To its credit, the ESP intervenes quite unobtrusively, however it needs to work overtime as on a bumpy road at speed the Levorg offers a ride akin to a bouncy castle. The vaunted Bilstein dampers installed in the GT-S feel like theyíve already done 300,000km; body control is virtually non-existent, the dampers crashing into the bump stops on even

The RS230 feels like it has the perfect amount of grunt for its chassis... its diff and rubber prove formidable

Numbers game

Load haulers hit the strip

SKODA OCTAVIA RS230

d motorof ficia 0-10km/h 0.64 0-20km/h 1.21 0-30km/h 1.8 0-40km/h 2.36 0-50km/h 3.07 0-60km/h 4.01 0-70km/h 4.72 0-80km/h 5.42 0-90km/h 6.13 0-100km/h 6.96 0-110km/h 7.92 0-120km/h 9.45 0-130km/h 10.51 0-140km/h 11.77 0-150km/h 13.23 0-160km/h 14.88 0-400m 15.03sec @ 160.58km/h 80-120km/h (3rd) 4.0sec 100-0km/h 39.2m

SPEED IN GEARS 1st 61km/h @ 6500rpm 2nd 110km/h @ 6500rpm 3rd 157km/h @ 6500rpm 4th 212km/h @ 6500rpm 5th 250km/h @ 6240rpm* 6th 250km/h @ 5250rpm* * Manufacturer's claim

SUBARU LEVORG GT-S

l f motor_mag 0-10km/h 0.43 0-20km/h 1.01 0-30km/h 1.53 0-40km/h 2.02 0-50km/h 2.63 0-60km/h 3.21 0-70km/h 3.84 0-80km/h 4.53 0-90km/h 5.34 0-100km/h 6.25 0-110km/h 7.29 0-120km/h 8.45 0-130km/h 9.75 0-140km/h 11.21 0-150km/h 12.91 0-160km/h 14.85 0-400m 14.48sec @ 158.06km/h 80-120km/h (Drive) 4.0sec 100-0km/h 39.5m

SPEED IN GEARS N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A As tested by MOTOR: Heathcote Dragway, 1.35pm, 31 degrees, dry, driver Louis Cordony

moderately sized hits and then pogo-ing on rebound, the body often taking a few oscillations to settle.

Thanks to Subaruís symmetrical all-wheel drive system the Levorg feels quite secure on the road, but it pitches and rolls and wallows under lateral or longitudinal load which can make placing it accurately difficult, particularly when the horribly light arcadegame steering offers next to no connection to the front end. At least itís not blighted by the persistent rack rattle that afflicts the STI.

To be honest the difference in outright pace between the two cars probably isnít much, but the experience each offers is worlds apart. The Skoda rewards the keen driver, whereas the Subaru feels so at sea approaching its limits that the driver is effectively discouraged from trying. Perhaps in the sea is where it would feel more at home, as thereís definitely a nautical flavour to its dynamic behaviour. Nor does it ride properly, constantly fidgeting over poor surfaces and bobbing and heaving over speed humps.

This is the most one-sided comparison in recent memory. Itís almost impossible to think of a scenario in which to recommend a Levorg. If you really want a Subaru and youíre not concerned with outright performance, save yourself $20,000 and buy the new Impreza hatch, and if you are, buy a WRX. And if you need more practicality, the Forester XT is superior to the Levorg in every aspect bar outright performance.

Which leaves the Skoda as the clear winner, but itís not a position it occupies by default.

The Octavia RS230 is a truly excellent car; engaging to drive, immensely practical and brilliant value. In outright ability it probably sits between four and four-and-a-half stars, however, weíre inclined to round up on this occasion to reward Skodaís bravery in importing this manual-only niche model. The performance wagon may be an endangered species, but itís the strong who survive. M

The Octavia RS230 is a truly excellent car; engaging to drive, immensely practical and brilliant value

The Specs

Czech Republic vs Japan

SKODA OCTAVIA RS230

BODY 5-door, 5-seat wagon DRIVE front-wheel ENGINE 1984cc inline-4cyl, DOHC, 16v turbocharger BORE/STROKE 82.5 x 92.8mm COMPRESSION 9.6:1 POWER 169kW @ 4700-6200rpm TORQUE 350Nm @ 1500-4600rpm POWER/WEIGHT 119kW/tonne TRANSMISSION 6-speed manual WEIGHT 1425kg SUSPENSION (F) struts, A-arms, coil springs, anti-roll bar SUSPENSION (R) multi-links, anti-roll bar L/W/H 4685/1814/1452mm WHEELBASE 2680mm TRACKS 1535/1506mm (f/r) STEERING electrically assisted rack-and-pinion BRAKES (F) 340mm ventilated discs, single-piston caliper BRAKES (R) 272mm solid discs, single-piston caliper WHEELS 19.0 x 7.5-inch (f/r) TYRE SIZES 225/35 R19 (f/r) TYRE Pirelli P Zero PRICE AS TESTED $43,190 PROS Great chassis; brilliant value; manual íbox CONS Non-killable ESP; steering a little off STAR RATING 11112

SUBARU LEVORG GT-S

BODY 5-door, 5-seat wagon DRIVE all-wheel ENGINE 1998cc boxer-4cyl, DOHC, 16v, turbocharger BORE/STROKE 86.0 x 86.0mm COMPRESSION 10.6:1 POWER 197kW @ 5600rpm TORQUE 350Nm @ 2400-5200rpm POWER/WEIGHT 122kW/tonne TRANSMISSION CVT WEIGHT 1622kg SUSPENSION (F) struts, coil springs, anti-roll bar SUSPENSION (R) multi-links, coil springs, anti-roll bar L/W/H 4690/1780/1490mm WHEELBASE 2650mm TRACKS 1530/1540mm (f/r) STEERING electrically assisted rack-and-pinion BRAKES (F) 316mm ventilated discs, 2-piston caliper BRAKES (R) 300mm ventilated discs, single-piston caliper WHEELS 18.0 x 7.5-inch (f/r) TYRE SIZES 225/45 R18 91W (f/r) TYRE Dunlop SP Sport Maxx 050 PRICE AS TESTED $48,890 PROS Well equipped; AWD security; looks good CONS Dreadful dynamics; characterless drivetrain STAR RATING 11233